Requirements:

Tend 15 Pirate Pigs
Harvest 50 Birds of Paradise
Craft 101 Remorseful Letters

Rewards:
Scallywagon, Pirate's Patch, Fertile Ash Boost
Notes: Pirate Pigs are a previous mission reward and in the Market. Remorseful Letters are Crafted.
Each Letter requires 1 Spanish Compensation (Gold Forges) and 1 Contrite Words (Wall Post)